A Unity of Will & Purpose

By James Holland and Brigadier (Ret.) Robbie Boyd

The global strategic fight is remarkably black and white and so is the choice that we in the democratic West face right now.

It is a stark choice because our enemies’ aims are so crystal clear. Quite simply, these are to erode the West’s collective strength and the cooperation that exists across alliances, coalitions, the forces of democratic freedom and our multilateral institutions. They also want to degrade our means of deterrence by any means and logic, albeit without – as yet – going onto an all-out war footing. Their methods are to undermine government spending, to promote far right-fuelled nationalism and they have even lit the touch-paper for liberal self-serving ideologies within the democracies and our institutions to push their own agendas. At the same time, they are relentlessly promoting far-left anti-defence spending arguments and violent protest across Europe, whilst galvanising the whole political spectrum to attack any individuals who consistently speak out to promote such increased spending on deterrence and resilience. We live in an age where the principle tool of social media swamps our daily lives and where conspiracy theories run rampant. Armies of Russian and Iranian social media bots operate around the clock to undermine western unity, common sense and co-operation. Millions of dollars are paid to help prop up those individuals and parties who promote separatism and disunity and social division. Those parties are not just ideologues – they are adversarial states.

Their strategy is to divide, break, and then win…piece by piece.

And it appears to be working. History tells us that in times of economic upheaval, the institutions of democracy are at their most vulnerable. Economic downturns are invariably followed by political turmoil. A century ago, the democracies faced an economically ruinous – and tragic – war, a global pandemic, a global financial crash and a global tariff war. This century, the West has faced two economically ruinous wars – Iraq and Afghanistan – a global crash in 2008, a global pandemic in 2020 and over the past eighteen months, a global tariff war that has so far cost us far more than sound investment in deterrence would have done. In the early 1930s, these collective upheavals led to war between Japan and China, civil war in Spain, the rise of the dictators, the advent of Hitler and Nazi Germany, and the failure of appeasement. What then followed was the most calamitous global conflict the world has ever known and 85 million dead, borders ripped up, tens of millions displaced and destruction on a level never before witnessed. The Second World War should be the greatest single warning for future generations that anyone should need and yet today, as it slips from living memory, we’re badly forgetting what that catastrophe meant for the world.

Look around. The United States, the prime creator of modern progressive democracy, the bulwark of the Four Freedoms – of speech and religion and from fear and want – now has a president who appears to be in thrall to the Russian leader. Putin is a mass murderer, the instigator of an illegal war that has already cost millions – millions – of casualties, and whose corruptions are endemic. There’s a strong suspicion that Putin has some kind of kompromat on Trump. How else to explain the repeated efforts to undermine Ukraine? Why else would the United States renege on the Budapest Memorandum of 1994, when Ukraine agreed to transfer its nuclear warheads to Russia in return for a assurances from the US, Britain and Russia respecting that nation’s independence, sovereignty and existing borders? What other reason is there for Trump doing a deal with Russia for diesel when he could have done so with American’s neighbour and ally, Canada? And why else would he repeatedly praise Putin and demean and criticise the democratic President Zelensky of Ukraine and the nation the USA pledged to protect? Trump has a photo of himself with Putin pride of place in the White House, for goodness sake.

Or look at Britain right now. On the one hand there is Nigel Farage and the Reform Party, spreading the language of separatism and disunity under the faux mantra of a misplaced mythological past that never existed. They’re now awash with untold millions, much of which appears to have come via a fundraising conduit who is also a convicted fraudster and who now lives in Montenegro – of all places – where there are plenty of Russians and plenty of Russian money. He’s made unusual transfers of funds and used crypto exchanges with a worrying lack of transparency. A cynic would be forgiven for wondering whether laundering and the malevolent hand of Russia is at play. Or what about the Green Party, which emerged in the early 1970s and which was very firmly based on environmental concerns – concerns that were exacerbated by the very obvious threat of global warming? Caroline Lucas and Jean Lambert, the first elected Green Members of the European Parliament, won their seats on environmental issues and championing a ban on genetically modified food.

The Green Party today doesn’t appear to give a toss about saving bees or curlews but has put anti-Zionism at the core of their political doctrine. The lines between anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism – which saw six million Jews murdered in the Second World War – are very blurred indeed. Why else would the Greens be so especially concerned with the fate of Palestinians rather than, for example, the persecuted Muslin Uyghurs in China, who are locked up in ‘re-education’ camps and facing sterilisation? Or why not champion the fate of Afghans, women especially, now at the mercy of the misogynistic and deeply repressive Taliban regime? Or why are they not defending the Christians of Somalia, of Nigeria, of Mali, of Burkina Faso, of Congo and Mozambique? Or the Yazidis, one of the oldest religions in the world, persecuted beyond comprehension in Northern Iraq? Why would the Greens target Israel – and Zionism – so blatantly when Hamas is as fundamentally cruel, corrupt, misogynistic and anti-freedom as the despotic and similarly aligned Iranian regime for whom they are proxies? The Greens are a British political party. What on earth is going on? Isn’t it disgusting that Jews in this country are facing a wave anti-Semitism, eighty years only after the Holocaust?

And where, people, is the collective resistance to this? How can the millions and millions of law-abiding and decent human beings put up with these corruptions and distortions on our doorsteps? How can any sane person support someone as blatantly corrupt, cruel and malevolent as Trump or as sinister as, say, Reform and the Greens in the UK?

It’s because our faith in institutions is being repeatedly challenged. As Professor Jennifer Brinkerhoff of The George Washington University has pointed out, ‘We’ve lost the deliberative of deliberative democracy.’ By this, she means that modern democratic political systems have stripped away or abandoned the core practice of careful, reasoned, and open public discussion, leaving behind only a hollow shell of voting and increased polarisation. In the US this week, people may vote to deal a hammer blow to the most unpopular president of the past century, but with no great enthusiasm for the Democrats, whose collective approval rating is worse even than that of Trump’s.

The political extremes in Europe – the AfD, National Rally, Lega, PVV, FPÖ, Reform, the Greens and so on – are attracting the politics of hatred and division, not unity. Like Reform, many have been caught red-handed taking Russian money. Some are already in prison for accepting bribes, when a more appropriate charge could be treason. None of these populist parties are promoting a better, fairer democracy for all. Nor, just as importantly, will those who vote for them find themselves better off; quite the reverse. Wrecking ball politicians in democracies always make the nation and people poorer. Yet there is at best weary resignation amongst voters: disillusionment, a lack of confidence that anyone will do much to improve things, that cans are repeatedly being kicked down the road by a succession of weak, unimaginative governments lacking vision and an inability to inspire. Those on the right also amplify ongoing concerns about illegal immigration and the cultural shifts and threats this brings, rather than finding pragmatic, workable solutions. Nor are there any attempt to create projects – such as some form of national service, whether public works or military – that would provide skills, opportunities and, perhaps most importantly, greater social cohesion.

Undermining them further is the Blob – the computer-says-no big state with its grey suits and unwillingness to challenge the status quo. Those in government, all too many believe, and with some justification, are powerless to confront this brick wall. At a recent talk, former British Prime Minister, Theresa May, told her audience, ‘If you are a really good minister, the Civil Servants will not stop you.’

Hmm. That same day, the Defence Secretary, John Healey, was blocked by his SPADs – special advisors – from supporting Britain joining the Defence, Security and Resilience Bank, the DSRB. This is an institution conceived by British financiers and former military personnel and based very much on the model of the World Bank or IMF. In other words, it offers triple-A assurance, long-term, low-interest loans on the back of government bonds from the founder nations. Such loans can, should a government choose to do so, be kept ‘off the books’ of national debt. The DSRB is also open to private institutions and is designed specifically to boost defence and resilience spending amongst NATO and democratic nations. At a time where greater deterrences are desperately needed, this is a very sensible way in which to give cash-strapped Europe, especially, a massive kick-start. It’s the same principle, by the way, that allowed the cash-strapped and massively indebted USA to become the arsenal of democracy – and with it comfortably the richest nation on the planet – during and after World War II. There is not a economist or financier I have spoken who does not believe greater defence spending has the potential to help grow economies. Poland, spending nearly 5% of GDP on defence at present, is a case in contemporary point.

The DSRB could have been based in London with all the knock-on benefits such an august institution would have brought, but the SPADs at the Treasury said no. Why? That’s not clear. Perhaps because it wasn’t their idea. They instinctively recoil from change and any kind of outsider influence. Or maybe because of petty jealousies. Or undermining outside influence from our enemies. Who knows? Instead, they came up with their own version, the Multilateral Defence Mechanism – MDM – on the back of encouraging murmurings from the Dutch and the Poles. In the meantime, the DSRB has been championed by the West’s current hero, Mark Carney, Prime Minister of Canada. He’s also the former Governor of the Bank of England and knows a thing or two about economics. And under Carney’s championing, Canada will be signing its Articles of Agreement for the DSRB in Luxembourg on 30 November this year, 2026, alongside Albania, Turkey, Greece, Latvia, Luxembourg, Belgium and Romania as fellow founder members. Billions will then flow into those countries for investment in defence related businesses and projects. Britain could have been a part of this with billions also flowing into the UK economy. There is no date for the creation of the MDM. At the moment, it remains purely a paper proposal and almost certainly, it will never become anything more. It is destined to be a worse version of Beta, playing second-fiddle to VHS.

What is so frustrating is that John Healey is a great enthusiast for the DSRB and so too is Al Carns and other cabinet members and ministers besides. However, a source tells us that when Healey subsequently arrived with Treasury officials to negotiate with the Canadians to merge the MDM with the DSRB, a SPAD said, ‘What our minister meant to say was…’ in a scene straight from Yes, Minister. The very day that Theresa May was saying how vital it was ministers showed civil servants who was boss, the Government made an announcement that Britain would not be joining the DSRB. The result is blindingly obvious: Prime Minister Andy Burnham has lost a way to rapidly finance urgently needed deterrence decisions and British defence financiers will have to wave goodbye to a source of 80% guarantees on their investments into UK defence companies that now remain at the mercy of expensive financing from venture capitalists instead. Inevitably, they will start to move out of the UK to find cheaper investment financing in nations participating in the DSRB. What the heck? How can we be this woefully inept? The current government has a whopping parliamentary majority and there are also plenty in the opposition similarly enthused by what joining the DSRB might offer. That we’re not joining is really hard to comprehend. Can unelected civil servants really hold such sway over our government as to effectively promote their own anti-deterrence ideology? Tragically, it appears so. The emasculation of John Healey is testimony of this, while the Russians must be laughing as such a cheap win.

The erosion of deliberative democracy has spread its web across Europe. Despite lofty talk of a ‘coalition of the willing’ there is no convincing effort yet to stop the divisions that are running rampant through the democracies at present. With the exception of NATO and the DSRB developers, no-one is successfully promoting the case for unity or stressing the vital tenet that in unity we can deter our enemies. Instead, officials, unions, and finance ministries across Europe are working to divide the institutions we built – and Carney is building – to ensure peace and are instead undermining the honest advice of experts – and not just words of warning from former generals but academics, business leaders and others who are repeatedly speaking out and equally repeatedly finding their warnings to be falling on fallow ground and amongst deaf ears.

President Roosevelt’s State of the Union address on 6 January 1941

There is no shortage of brilliant and enlightened people in our democracies. There is no shortage of manpower. There is actually plenty of wealth still too. Democracies, though, require people to buy into the notion of a greater good and to support social cohesion and collective responsibility. I’ve been in Normandy this week and a visit to the British Normandy Memorial and the American cemetery above Omaha Beach are reminders of what price has to be paid when the forces of evil are allowed to unite and when democracy fails, as it did in Germany and elsewhere. ‘This embattled shore, portal of freedom, is forever hallowed by the ideals, valor and the sacrifices of our fellow countrymen,’ is etched into the top of the columns at the entrance the beautiful, tragic and profoundly moving American cemetery. Eisenhower’s memoir was called Crusade in Europe. In his State of the Union address in January 1941, President Franklin D. Roosevelt warned, ‘We must guard against divisions among ourselves and among all other United Nations.’ He also warned against any kind of racial discrimination. ‘Hitler will try again to breed mistrust and suspicion between one individual and another, one group and another, one race and another, one Government and another. He will try to use the same technique of falsehood and and rumour-mongering with which he divided France from Britain. He is trying to do this with us even now.’ Sound familiar?

‘But,’ Roosevelt vowed, ‘he will find a unity of will and purpose against him, which will persevere until the destruction of all his black designs.’ Damn right, and FDR was as good as his word. What subsequently won the war was precisely the kind of vision and single-mindedness of unity and purpose that makes democracies unbeatable when they choose to pull together. In fact, D-Day was in many ways the apogee of coalition, co-operation and co-ordination – democratic nations coming together despite different cultures and ambitions, for one single purpose. It was spectacularly successful but what a terrible tragedy it was that D-Day had to be mounted in the first place.

We in the West are standing on a precipice. Too melodramatic? Too hyperbolic? Sadly, not. If we don’t rapidly and dramatically start standing together once more and resist this global strategic attack, our children and grandchildren are going to be screwed. Let’s call out every divider. And let’s find the tools so that leaders can cooperate globally to resist this.

It is time to pick a side and to fight for it.

James Holland (FRHistS) is a renowned English historian, author and broadcaster, who specialises in the history of the Second World War.

Brigadier (Ret.) Robbie Boyd is deterrence financier who was Senior Leader at the Defence, Security and Resilience Bank (DSRB) Development Group, and is currently CEO of ENCompass BV. Previously he served as a Commanding Officer in the British Army, later assuming the role of Deputy Head for NATO and Europe Policy at the Ministry of Defence and Political and Military Adviser to the Chair of the NATO Military Committee.

Previous Article: